Analysts' Recommendations and What They Mean

Do you find that analysts' recommendations are confusing? It is not so bad when you realize that almost all analysts' recommendation are on a 5 point scale.

Most places where you find a collection of analysts' recommendations, they will be using a 5 point system, and they will make a consensus call based on what the majority of the stock analysts think, according to this scale.

Say, according to Morning Call, there are 9 analysts and 5 say a stock is a buy, 3 say a buy/hold and 1 say hold. You should consider this a buy. If you take the Morning Call ratings, you would give the buys 1 point for each analyst (or 5 points) and buy/hold 2 points for each analyst (or 6 points) and the hold 3 points for each analyst (or 3 points) for a total of 19 points. Divide by 9 to get 1.5, which is a buy.

The Globe & Mail no longer gives out ratings. However, Morning Call rates stocks as Buy (1), Buy/Hold (2), Hold (3), Hold/Sell (4) and Sell (5). See their recommendations at their site.

Another place to get analysts' recommendations is at 4 Traders. They use ratings of Buy (1), Outperform (2), Hold (3), Underperform (4) and Sell (5).

Possible ratings you will come across are:

1	2	3	4	5
Strong Buy	Buy	Hold	Underperform	Sell
Buy	Buy/Hold	Hold	Hold/Sell	Sell
Buy	Overweight	Hold	Underweight	Sell
Buy	Buy/Hold	Hold	Weak Hold	Sell
Action Buy	Buy	Hold	Reduce	Sell
Buy	Outperform	Hold	Underperform	Sell
Buy	Outperform	Market Perform	Underperform	Sell
Buy	Outperform	Sector Perform	Underperform	Sell
Strong Buy	Moderate Buy	Hold	Moderate Sell	Strong Sell
Top Pick	Buy	Hold	Don't Buy	Sell
Strong Buy	Accumulate	Neutral		Swap
Top Pick	Buy	Outperform	Market Perform	Underperform
	Overweight	Equal Weight	Underweight
	Outperform	In line	Underperform

Got a Buy on Weakness or Watch recommendation? Generally this is because they think that the price is currently too high and it might go lower. Sometimes the "Don't Buy" recommendation is meant as a Hold.

On my other blog I am today writing about Transcontinental Inc. (TSX-TCL.A, OTC-TCLAF) ... continue...

This blog is meant for educational purposes only, and is not to provide investment advice. Before making any investment decision, you should always do your own research or consult an investment professional. I do research for my own edification and I am willing to share. I write what I think and I may or may not be correct.

See my site for an index to these blog entries and for stocks followed. Follow me on Twitter.